I have always thought the All-Star teams were not a great basis for judging a player's season. The MLB All-Star teams are voted on by fans and they have 25 or so players and sometimes a player is only there to represent a team. Nonetheless, it is one measure. We will post the AP, the UPI, and The Sporting News Teams as well.
Here are the NL starts for the 1977 All-Star game at Yankee Stadium.
Johnny Bench, Cincinnati (MLB)
1B—Steve Garvey, Los Angeles (MLB, AP, UPI, TSN)
3B—Mike Schmidt, Philadelphia (AP, UPI, TSN)
Ron Cey, Los Angeles (MLB)
SS—Gary Templeton, St. Louis (AP, UPI, TSN)
Dave Concepcion, Cincinnati (MLB)
OF—George Foster, Cincinnati (MLB, AP, UPI, TSN)
OF—Greg Luzinski, Philadelphia (MLB, AP, UPI, TSN)
OF—George Foster, Cincinnati (MLB, AP, UPI, TSN)
OF—Greg Luzinski, Philadelphia (MLB, AP, UPI, TSN)
RHP—Tom Seaver, Cincinnati (AP, UPI)
Don Sutton, Los Angeles (MLB)
Relief—Bruce Sutter, Chicago (UPI)
Consensus Second-team
C—Johnny Bench, Cincinnati (AP, UPI)
1B—Willie McCovey, San Francisco (AP)
1B—Willie McCovey, San Francisco (AP)
Tony Perez, Montreal (UPI)
2B—Rennie Stennett, Pittsburgh (AP, UPI)
3B—Ron Cey, Los Angeles (AP)
2B—Rennie Stennett, Pittsburgh (AP, UPI)
3B—Ron Cey, Los Angeles (AP)
Dave Concepcion, Cincinnati (UPI)
OF—Reggie Smith, Los Angeles (AP, UPI)
OF—Jeff Burroughs, Atlanta (AP, UPI)
OF—Bobby Murcer, Chicago (AP-t)
OF—Lou Brock, St. Louis (AP-t)
OF—Reggie Smith, Los Angeles (AP, UPI)
OF—Jeff Burroughs, Atlanta (AP, UPI)
OF—Bobby Murcer, Chicago (AP-t)
OF—Lou Brock, St. Louis (AP-t)
OF—Dave Winfield, San Diego (UPI)
LHP—Tommy John, Los Angeles (AP, UPI-t)
John Candelaria, Pittsburgh (UPI-t)
RHP—Rick Reuschel, Chicago (AP)
RHP—Rick Reuschel, Chicago (AP)
Relief—Rollie Fingers, San Diego (UPI)
Goose Gossage, Pittsburgh (UPI)
And finally here is the ML WAR All-Star Team—
Ted Simmons on his best day wasn't as good as Bench on Johnny's worst day. But Simmons could hit...
ReplyDeleteagree 100%
DeleteGood research. We all know this pretty much. The question then is
DeleteAnd?
well, you pretty much didn't know the Ap and UPI All-Star teams. They just recently appeared on baseball reference---and that is new info that you got here first.
DeleteAfter that it is just information showing the WAR versus the teams voted on by the fans and the media.
That is the "and"